IPHONE GAME REVIEW
Rock Band (iPhone)We've got the beat |
 |
Product: Rock Band (iPhone)
| Publisher: Electronic Arts
| Format: iPhone
| Genre: Multiplayer, Music/
Rhythm
| Players: 1
| Networking: wireless (network), Bluetooth
| Version: US
| App version: 1.0.0
The best song in the world can sound unpleasant if the band is out of tune. Rock Band is right on pitch when it comes to Bluetooth multiplayer, affordable song packs, and great rhythmic gameplay, yet its vocals are about a half-step off the mark.
Guitar, bass, drums, and vocals - Rock Band brings them together to form a virtual band guided by taps of your fingers. It's the same basic rhythmic gameplay that made the series a hit on consoles and PSP transposed for touchscreen play.
Notes stream down the screen along four coloured note tracks, and tapping the corresponding buttons at the bottom plays the notes as they pass. Special guitar solos add flair, although drum fills are sadly absent.
Nailing passages of special glowing notes grants overdrive, activated by flicking your handset. The effect of doubling your points multiplier naturally nets you more points, which in turn increases your star performance rating critical to progress in the game's single player World Tour mode.
Five venues, each possessing a four-track setlist, serve as stops in World Tour. Posting three-star performances on the first four tracks of each location unlocks the hidden fifth. Pass this song and you open up the next stop on the tour. Don't worry, though - you don't have to channel the skill of Jimi Hendrix to draw crowds.
It's pretty easy getting through World Tour mode thanks to simple note choreography and the ability to switch instruments between songs. Reducing the number of note tracks by one from the series' standard five automatically lowers the difficulty, though the note patterns are generally simpler than those on console and PSP.
Not being forced to stick with one instrument through the course of World Tour mode also makes it much easier to complete. You're granted freedom to choose whichever instrument suits you best, so if you're unable to make it through a tune on guitar you can try again on bass or drums.
It's also beneficial in allowing you to avoid the abysmal vocals setup. Instead of seizing the potential for compelling vocal play with the built-in microphone on iPhone, Rock Band opts for a pathetic tap mechanic that makes Fergie seem like an operatic diva. Similar to guitar, bass, and drums, you tap notes as they stream across the screen - this time they scroll right to left rather than top to bottom.
Lame is the only way to describe it. Why you would want to play vocals over the other instruments is beyond us, if only because the mechanic is essentially the same. Had a mechanic been devised that more appropriately reflected vocal play, perhaps there would be a reason to actually try it out.
Guitar, bass, and drums still entertain and the game's multiplayer and in-app purchasing features provide a nice encore once World Tour has been completed.
Bluetooth cooperative multiplayer enables you to strike up a band with up to three friends, each person taking up an instrument. It's a great feature, though real-time competitive and full network play are missing. Additionally, there's no customisable avatar, which would be ideal given the Facebook component.
New tracks can be purchased from within the game, coming in conveniently priced pairs. At 59p/99c, they're reasonable enough to be competitive against Tap Tap Revenge 3. It's also worth noting that these iPhone downloads are significantly discounted from their PSP and console counterparts that routinely ring up at double the price for a single track.
The only unpleasant note regards the track selection. Compared to the wide range of genres available in Tap Tap Revenge 3 - dance, pop, rock, fusion - Rock Band goes for a purer rock 'n' roll line up. That limits its appeal, despite it having superior gameplay.
Rock Band is ultimately only as strong as its weakest member and its lame vocals prevent it from bringing down the house. Bluetooth multiplayer and reasonably priced song packs keeps it entertaining, though better vocal play, personalised avatars, and expanded multiplayer options are needed before it becomes a show fully worth taking on the road.
Rock Band (iPhone) |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
Disappointing vocals play and lack of customisable avatars have Rock Band going flat, but solid rhythmic gameplay, Bluetooth multiplayer and competitively priced song downloads keep it sharp
|
| |
|
Flea | 20 October 2009
Are you not aware that there is no microphone on iPod Touch?
OJ | 20 October 2009
Obviously he's aware...He's just saying that itwould be a nice addition to both. And as a matter of fact new touches ship with an inline mic
dumas1000 | 21 October 2009
Meh, the timing window is brutal. The buttons are cramped. Good luck playing this game on hard mode unless you have reasonably small hands and/or thumbs. The timing window issue is a bit of a turn-off with the PSP version as well. TTR3 is more enjoyable IMO, even though I fully realize that you are not "interacting" with the music on TTR. The patterns in TTR are still fun to play. I'm a huge fan of the console Rock Band too. The overall packaging is really stripped down and basic for the iPhone as well. I don't have or want a Facebook account. DLC is not incorporated into tour mode. No customization. Not really impressed. Beatrider and TTR have the timing window right. DDR, Rock Band and the now defunct TapStar all got it wrong.
joni | 24 October 2009
i think guitar rock tour 1 and 2 are better , they have got better songs and graphics too !!
