IPHONE GAME REVIEW
Mecho WarsOne good turn deserves another |
 |
Product: Mecho Wars
| Developer: Luc Bernard
| Format: iPhone
| Genre: Strategy
| Players: 1
| Networking: on one device
| Version: US
| App version: 1.0
Peer through the scaffolding of any highrise undergoing construction and you can discern the strength of the structure. Even when a building is far from complete, it's easy to see quality in the works.
Mecho Wars is like gawking at some incomplete tower jutting onto the horizon, its creative potential tucked within a maze of struts and supporting beams.
Commanding wonderfully bizarre units on land, air, and in the seas, Mecho Wars chronicles the war between the terrestrial Landian race and ornate Winged Crusade. Startling advances by invading Landian forces prompt you to lead the Winged Crusade in a daring counteroffensive.
A single player campaign spanning more than a dozen missions follows hour-by-hour the effort to root out the Landian aggressors.
Missions play out in turns, each hour of the day serving as a turn. During a turn, you're able to move units about the map, attack enemies, and capture buildings. Units are commissioned from bases using cash accumulated at the beginning of every turn based on the number of cities under your control. The maximum number of units you're allowed to build is reliant upon how many bases you possess: for each seized, the cap is raised by two.
The units themselves are unique by design, though they stick to convention when it comes to combat abilities. Heavy units hold superiority over infantry, which themselves have an upper arm against flying forces. There are specific qualities that have been borrowed from other turn-based games as well, such as infantry being the only units capable of capturing buildings and long range cannons possessing vulnerability to direct attacks.
Visually, little signifies the difference between a tank-like, direct-attacking Elpho and a short range assault Mage that has a similar look. Pronounced visual cues highlighting these distinctions would help.
Mecho Wars goes well beyond drafting interesting units in its creative interpretation of turn-based strategy. Invention abounds. The hour-by-hour structure of play, for instance, has a direct impact on the condition of the map.
During each turn, the environment has a chance to act after you and your opponent have taken turns. From the hours of 12:00a to 5:00a, water freezes to allow safe passage of ground units over rivers and oceans. This has a dramatic impact and fundamentally changes the nature of play in a unique way.
Other elements set the game apart, such as the inability to recoup lost hit points by situating a unit on a base. Only infantry can restore health using special cacti, not controlled structures. This initial annoyance actually forces you to be mindful about rushing units into battle without a clear strategy: in other words, it causes you to contrive a plan instead of just chucking units at the enemy.
This brilliant breed of tactical gameplay unfortunately butts up against a glaring lack of features. Multiplayer comes only in the form of pass-and-play on a single device. Support for local multiplayer battles on two devices (either Bluetooth or wi-fi) is oddly omitted as well.
An option for online play, which has been promised in a future free update, unfairly taunts from the multiplayer menu. Releasing the game with the mode in the menu is unacceptable: it makes the game appear conspicuously incomplete.
A slew of other minor improvements and additions can be made to bring Mecho Wars up to speed with rival titles. Additional multiplayer maps, a map editor, the introduction of hero units and special powers, and even a ranking system for judging your performance would give the game greater dimension.
Mecho Wars furnishes the foundation of a creative strategy game but needs more content and polish to reach its full potential. Once the gaps have been filled with updates and the scaffolding can be cleared away, then this inventive game will live up to its promise.
Mecho Wars |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
A highly original turn-based strategy game that has been released too early, resulting in the omission of content and features critical for polished gameplay and lasting value
|
| |
|
Joined:
Oct 2008
Post count:
5
"Highly original"?
It looks like a blatant rip-off of Advance Wars to me.
Anthony Afterwit | 24 June 2009
I can't believe the review didn't mention the most glaring problem, which for me makes the game unplayable. There's no way to know the stats of enemy units! How much damage are they capable of? What kind of counters are needed? How do they expect you to make any meaningful tactical decisions without this info?! So... it's a guessing game, and for me anyway, a waste of time. For now, Uniwar remains the only good turn based strategy game of this kind. I feel ripped off after paying $4.99 for an app which is basically unfinished. Apparently, they've lowered the price now, but I wouldn't even spend the .99 for this half-baked strategy game. Yes, it looks cool, but looks aren't everything.
Joined:
May 2009
Post count:
44
I'd agree that's a fairly major issue with the game, Anthony. Check out our recent interview with the game's designer, Luc Bernard. He mentions that his team is in the process of rectifying these issues for the first update.
Mr. Dave | 27 June 2009
Yeah, they make absolutely no mention of Advance Wars by Nintendo, which I'm sure borrowed a lot from other turn-based strategy games, but it seems ridiculous not to metion Nintendo's series.
Joined:
May 2007
Post count:
838
As a rule at Pocket Gamer, we try to avoid making direct comparisons in reviews, in favour of judging each game on its own merits. If something is very obviously derivative, we'll give it a grilling for that (if indeed we review it at all), but generally, we try to keep comparisons to a minimum. It's the only fair way. Hope that answers the above queries.
Advanced Wars fan | 30 June 2009
So pocketgamer does not think this game is blindly copying core mechanics of Advanced Wars? Well, that really does say something about how well are pocketgamer writers educated in video games ;-)
Joined:
Mar 2008
Post count:
173
Actually, if you consult the various interviews we've previously run with the game's creator Luc Bernard, he's mentioned Advance Wars several times. In the context of this review, there was no need to mention it again.
Joined:
Dec 2008
Post count:
939
Ok I just played this game on v1.0.1
Game is absolutely amazing! I completed the first campaign mode in one sitting! Stayed up to 3am - just could not put it down.
Critisisms:
1. Absolutely no story, cut scenes, or voice acting (-1)
2. Map artwork is much more interesting than battle sequence artwork - turned off battle sequences. I should not want to disable anything in a game! (-0.5)
3. Should have an option to toggle "Map Effects" on/off. Dev's should take notes from Magic the gathering card PC game, utilizing attack/defend icons and slash marks to signify active units - this would be great for those that want to turn battle sequences off. (-0.5)
I would give a (-1) for a short game, but the dev's added another campaign mode, so they get a thumbs up.
But seriously, my #1 and #2 complaints are inexcusable! I should deduct more points for those negative points. I really think the dev's should fix these things in future iterations (but really should fix the problems in the current version)
Conclusion:
Despite my harsh critiques, this game is made from the ground up for the iDevice and it shows! - no loading at all! Mecho Wars in its current state is THE turn based strategy RPG standard of the iDevice. This game is impossible to put down!
But it @ any price!
tim
